This brewery, as a rule, rocks. However, even rockers have their weak links. In this case, it is BCS. This was, in a word, "blecch!" It had the basis for a great stout (pretty impressive, coming from me, every Guiness fan's worst dream), but it was the chocolate additive that killed it. I won't hold it against trying new Brooklyn products, but this one is definitely off my "must try" list.